The Guard position is widely considered the thing that separates Jiu-jitsu from the other grappling arts. Having said that, you don’t need a great guard to have a long and successful Jiu-jitsu career.
What is Guard?
Guard is just what it sounds like. A bottom position whose intent is to minimize the potential for damage from the person in the top position. To “guard” from strikes and manage distance.
Sport application has turned guard practice into something else entirely. Remember – No rules. No time limit. No weight classes.
When the context of a thing’s founding principles are removed, the thing is almost bound to become something else entirely. Having said that, I don’t want to let these posts go down the path of pointing out what something isn’t.
As a beginner, or as someone who might be struggling on their current path, I’m here to tell you that you don’t need to spend much energy at all developing a guard. In fact, I would propose that your time would be better spent learning what to do *when* your guard gets passed. Not only that, but maybe even prefer that they do.
Let them pass.
Well, let them get around your legs, anyway. I know that sounds crazy, but it’s my opinion that your energy would be far better spent countering the pass and denying chest-to-chest contact. Why chest-to-chest? If their chest is touching your chest, you’re probably already on the way to being flattend out on your back, and that’s the thing we desperately need to avoid. Play with that at your next practice. Let them around your legs and make your only goal not letting their chest touch your chest so that you can get to your knees. Develop that skill, and them “passing” becomes much less worrisome.
Back injury.
Excessive guard play absolutely leads to back pain. I’m pretty sure that’s when my back spasms really took off, and I’m not alone in that. If it’s not overuse from the constant pulling motion from your likely underdeveloped hip flexors. pain will eventually also come from hyperflexion through repeatedly having your weight stacked onto your neck and shoulders.
Complexity.
Guard’s main tool is your legs, and they’re used primarily for control. It takes a long time and purposeful effort to develop a high level of both dexterity and motor control required to keep a resisting person in place. That’s just maintaining the position. To try and manipulate them into sweeps and submissions is far more difficult.
Efficiency.
Submissions from your back are far less efficient than submissions from top positions. They have the use of gravity and a generally higher degree of mobility. Developing the skills required to control a resisting opponent with your legs takes a long time and a lot more effort than learning sweep, reversals, and guard pass counters. By getting to the top positions, now you are in a better position for leveraging the advantages of weight and mobility for not only pinning positions but also positional advances and submissions.
I’m not of the opinion that newer people should put much focus on re-guarding techniques. The suggestion is that they passed your guard. It’s safe to reasonably assume that they know how to do it and will probably do it twice if they need to. Meanwhile, you’ve exerted a ton of energy and likely made some potentially compromising errors (posting, as discussed in an earlier blog). Again, let’s look into counters and reversals and work towards the top position.
Take care of yourself.